Dusk Maiden of Amnesia Review

Hello there. This is review number thirty three. Yes, it’s part of the Spring anime line up. There was actually huge hype when this anime was released so I had to bite my hand several times to stop myself from watching it while it was on going. I’m talking about Tasogare Otome x Amnesia or Dusk Maiden of Amnesia.

Judging by the gloomy picture it had on MAL, I thought the anime would be like XXXholic or something. I imagine it to be something scary yet exciting. The long haired chick does look cute. That’s enough to pick an anime up, right? Haha. Anyways, its twelve episodes long. Let’s read on.

Story

There’s a popular story at Seikyou Academy about a girl named Yuuko.

Yuuko is a ghost with amnesia. She’s also the president of the detective club.

Before I knew it, I was stuck with her. Literally, as I later realize.

Taking the Pants Off

Dusk Maiden of Amnesia is intriguing at first. In Sankarea, there is a boy who loved a zombie. Here in this anime, there is a boy that loves a ghost. I loved that premise because I can’t imagine doing something fulfilling with such a concept. Sankarea didn’t struggle with its concept so I placed the same faith for this anime. Well the Dusk Maiden of Amnesia was certainly unique and it had potential but sadly, it was poorly conceived.

The anime had a nice theme of horror and the supernatural at its disposal. The setting was perfect as it had an air of eeriness in it. The mood was really scary and the music was alive when something scary was about to pop out. The anime should’ve taken that route but they took an ecchi route. I can’t believe it because I was sold on its horror elements. The first half of the anime though was all about ecchi. We have the two main characters do nothing but flirt. There is the ghost named Yuuko Kanoe, who looks a hell of a lot like Senjougahara of Bakemonogatari, which does nothing but happily cling to the one boy who can see her and can understand her pain. Then there is our lead, Teiichi Niiya, who enjoys being flirted with and also enjoys grabbing our heroine’s boobs. During some of the creepy and intense moments, the two of them would suddenly flirt and so the scary atmosphere would lighten up to give the couple some alone time.

That ecchi aspect, that reminds me of Kanokon, was a bit out of place. The anime had a nice story going about the mysteries and legends surrounding the school that the paranormal club investigates. The best part is that they weren’t just random scary stories to spook people out, the mysteries tie in with the main plot and so the story slowly snowballs. It became so interesting and each mystery helps develop it. That’s why I didn’t appreciate the ecchi elements. What do you want more a scary story or an ecchi story? I prefer a scary story as the industry rarely gives us a scary anime.

The anime has this nice message of not believing legends and rumors that has no foundation. It speaks of how some stories can be twisted and some of its facts dismissed. So a story a cursed rock can just be a huge ass rock commemorating an important event. The anime try to kill its horror aspect that way. It’s as if it’s telling the audience to stop believing in ghost stories and think. It’s a bit insulting but a nice message either way.

The anime did get better on the second half when the ecchi was toned down a bit and the anime decided to get serious. It tackled the mystery surrounding the anime and we slowly discover the reason why Yuuko has amnesia and how she ended up dead in the school. It’s a great mystery too. That part of the plot was enough to make me forget the rather boring first half of the anime.

There are only four characters in the anime. The rest are one shot and the scenes are often empty places in the school so there is barely anyone else in the anime. At first I loved how there is such a small cast and so we have more time to focus on the plot. The problem is that the characters are boring. They fall on the same archetype we have seen over and over again. Niiya isn’t really that impressive of a lead and Yuuko isn’t that interesting. If Yuuko had a smidge of refinement like Rea from Sankarea then she would’ve been so much better. The only reason the characters shine is because of their role in the plot and the mystery looming over the anime. The other isn’t all that great too but was honestly much better than the leads. It’s pretty shitty how the supporting characters are more memorable than the main characters.

It’s rare for the story to be good and the characters to be boring. The anime lacked a bit of focus it ultimately plays out well. It had a nice theme of love. It’s a love that overcomes all restrictions and all challenges. It’s a love that breaks all the rules. It’s a love that was buried over all the ecchi stuff but slowly unravels itself.

Sight and Sound

The anime had a nice air of horror in it. The school is creepy and there seems to be no sign of life in it. The windows are dilapidated and the floors are making noises. Some of the classrooms are abandoned and turned into storages closets. Theirs is barely any sign of a busy school that sets up a pretty nice atmosphere for ghosts and other supernatural creatures to roam about.

The scenes during night time are even better. The clear sky and the beautiful horizon were captivating. It gives you an idea of how the evening can be scary yet beautiful at the same time. I do find the moon a bit odd. It’s flat but its only scenery, it doesn’t ruin the plot.

The anime also presents the mysteries pretty neatly with an effective visual. You are meant to be scared and had the anime not been ecchi, you will be scared. Especially when the music picks up pace and makes your heart beat fast.

The background music is indeed impressive. I can’t say the same for the opening. I find it weird and when the singer hits a high note with the words “choir jail”, it throws me off. What the hell is a choir jail? It did make you feel the horror element much better though. The ending song was more solemn and melancholic. I also love how they made Yuuko lip sync some of the parts.

The best music in the anime is this little insert song during the latter half of the anime. It was sad but it truly fits the anime to a tee. It captured the mood so perfectly that I can’t believe the anime didn’t use it as their opening/ ending song instead.

Overall Score

7/10 “An anime with potential ruined by an unwanted element.”

I hate ecchi and fan service when it’s presented in something that doesn’t need it. I hate the beach episode in Another so you can imagine how a constant ecchi theme ruins the supposed scary potential the anime have. The story is great and the mystery is paced properly. The anime isn’t perfect but it is worth the watch.

18 thoughts on “Dusk Maiden of Amnesia Review

      • lol yeah but i only like fan service when it fits in with the story being told … unlike *Ahem* Freezing or High School of the Dead which wallow in it which was kind of sad as both series had a lot of potential.

      • lol. but those anime were of the ecchi genre. they shine because of the ecchi. ok, so you want ecchi in your love stories and a serious story for your ecchi anime? lolwut?

      • no i merely prefer it to not be over done, despite some popular ideals there is such a thing as too much of a good thing. 😛

        • but ecchi is about being over done!!!
          aggressive girls, girlish guys, big boobs. its a celebration of all things great!!!
          you can spot an ecchi a mile away w/ the sexy girls. this anime had a girl in an old school uniform. it wasn’t ecchi.
          your looking for ecchi in all the wrong places.

  1. To me the series worked remarkably well, although the first half felt a little clunky and didn’t seem to know ehre it was going. I wasn’t bothered by the ecchi and feel that it fit Yuuko’s character as this whimsical ghost who simply wants someone to interact with. In the end to me it was a story of acceptance and perhaps less of a horror anime, which sounds a little strange when the central character is a ghost.

    • i kinda expected the anime to be as good as Sankarea though I don’t really know why. XD I agree, its clunky and it had potential to be something much better.
      I hated the ecchi though. Mainly because it reminds me of Kanokon and it dominated the supposed horror potential of the anime. The main problem is yeah, she’s a ghost but the horror is light hearted but its not a comedy anime cause its serious at times so it kinda fumbles on what the hell it really wants to be. An ecchi romance mystery anime with a touch of romance? I dunno, I’m not sold on the idea. XD

      • I disagree, it is a darkly comic series and in many ways you need to get away from thinking about as a horror anime. In many respects Yuuko being a ghost does not necessarily matter, the series is more about the power of stories to twist peoples perceptions of reality. The comedy works because it how Yuuko is escaping from her reality by messing around with Teiichi, along with showing us that she simply wanted to be noticed by someone. Instead of a ghost you could see Yuuko as someone who is ignored by everyone, much like in ‘Another’.

        I dont think it fumbles either and the dark comedy melds seamlessly (apart from a few instances during the first half) with the darker elements to do with Shadow Yuuko. I loved how Yuuko and Teiichi changed over the course of the series, and for me it was easily the best anime of last season, with the best finale by far.

      • so the dark aspect of this darkly comic isn’t suppose to give the idea of horror? if the only comedy they could pull is by having yuuko fool around w/ teiichi then they could give an entire episode of it, i don’t care. but if you already set up this scary atmosphere just to have this comedy slipped it then thats failure in execution.
        the anime should’ve focused on horror or comedy but they have the impressively scary red lady episode and a swimming episode. satisfying two extremes?

        see, you liked shadow yuuko because she had a nice horror aspect w/ her. the later half was also more leaning in the dark elements. they should’ve just used the dark elements through out instead of presenting a weak first half.

        best of the season. i dunno.
        tsuritama had a pretty nice finale and overall enjoyment factor. XD

  2. Pingback: Maiden anime | Imageyoo

  3. just finished watching it and was pleasantly impressed (in the sense that i think the story was AWESOME)
    ok so 1st background music check (good music = good mood)
    2nd the little mysteries snowballing into the big one – loved it (personally i think that was the anime’s forte – or story??dunno…)
    3rd quite indecisive-like in genre tho i bet my 2 cents on mystery romance with a dash of horror and ecchi
    4th you mentioned kanokon…there the female lead was the sexual predator so to say (just like here), tho’ there the male lead was a perv;
    5th i think the major offset here wasn’t the ecchi, but the lack of character quality (it was a mystery/character driven anime so once the mystery is gone, you’re left with the chars)
    Now I’m off to read the manga (or at least try it out – wish me luck XD)
    Good review. Keep ’em comin’…

    • this was such a long time ago lol. lets see….in hindsight, i do believe the blending of the genres work quite well. the director did a nice job bringing it all to life. i kinda hated the ecchi because the anime had horror and drama and those alone makes the anime great.
      after all, after a couple of months, all i remember is the great atmosphere of the anime and not the ecchi.
      the second half kinda had some good character development though, right? like when they reveal the mystery of the girl’s past.

      i think the anime deserves an 8. so i’ll go change that now.

      • character development quality is relative to the character in a way. by that I mean that a 1D char has a limited potential, and therefore there is only so much it can please the viewer or the anime. It wasn’t bad, but what can I say, I’m greedy, I want more! :))

Thoughts~

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s